Skip to main content
Entertainment

Why Supergirl couldn’t get off the ground

The DC tentpole movie was up against poor reviews and toxic fanboy culture

• less than 3 min read

TOPICS: Entertainment / Film, Television & Studio Business / Box Office Trends

You don’t need kryptonite to stop Supergirl when you have poor reviews, little interest in secondary superheroes, and a toxic online fandom. The DC tentpole movie had a worse opening weekend than even the oft-memed Morbius, earning $62.6 million globally on a reported $170 million budget.

The Milly Alcock-led movie is on track to lose, optimistically, $100 million to $120 million, per reports. And there is no shortage of reasons:

  • Most critics panned it. The film is rated as “rotten” on Rotten Tomatoes and has a 49/100 rating on Metacritic.
  • Whether it’s Morbius, Black Adam, or Thunderbolts, lesser-known comic book characters have struggled to find box office success in recent years.
  • The same can be said for female-led superhero movies, but with one compounding factor—online trolls have been known to pepper sites with negative reviews despite not having seen the movie.

Target missed: Supergirl was meant to appeal to Gen Z women, but 59% of the audience was male, and 65% was 26 or older, which are only encouraging numbers for dive bars.

To be continued: Analysts are hopeful about Clayface, the third movie in the new James Gunn-led DC Universe that’s out in October. And, next year, Man of Tomorrow brings back David Corenswet for the second Superman installment. Last year’s reboot earned a relatively solid $618.7 million globally.—DL

Become smarter in just 5 minutes

Morning Brew delivers quick and insightful updates about the business world every day of the week from Wall St. to Silicon Valley.

By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.

About the author

Dave Lozo

Morning Brew

Morning Brew delivers quick and insightful updates about the business world every day of the week from Wall St. to Silicon Valley.

By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.